Abstract
Hypertension is a leading
cardiovascular health risk for women and is closely associated with
pregnancy-related blood pressure complications. While hypertensive disorders of
pregnancy increase long-term cardiovascular disease risk, many women develop
postpartum hypertension despite normal blood pressure during pregnancy, making
pregnancy a key period for identifying future risk. Postpartum hypertension
often develops silently and is thought to originate from pregnancy-related
vascular and inflammatory changes. While the management of hypertension during
pregnancy follows standard treatment like non-gravid patients, growing evidence
emphasizes lifestyle interventions, including diet, that could have a profound
effect on hypertension. Emerging evidence suggests that maternal protein intake
and protein source during pregnancy may influence long-term blood pressure
outcomes. Higher intake of dairy and lean animal proteins, particularly fish,
appears protective, whereas higher red meat intake may increase risk. These
findings highlight pregnancy as an important opportunity for nutritional
strategies to support long-term maternal cardiovascular health.
Purpose: The
purpose of this review is to describe the pathophysiology of postpartum
hypertension and the current treatments of it, primarily focusing on the nutritional
interventions with an emphasis on the impact of protein intake as observed in
the current literature.
Keywords: Postpartum hypertension, Pregnancy, Animal
protein, Dairy protein, Vegetable protein
Abbreviations:
WHO:
World Health Organization; HTN: Hypertension; BP: Blood Pressure; BMI: Body
Mass Index; DASH: Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension; FFQ: Food Frequency Questionnaire
1. Introduction and Background
1.1.
Postpartum Hypertension Worldwide
The most common risk factor for death
in women worldwide is hypertension1. In 2019, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimated
10.8 million deaths globally were attributed to Hypertension (HTN), with nearly
50% occurring among women2,3. Further,
the prevalence of HTN, specifically among women of reproductive age, increased
(metric) globally4.
Importantly and unique to women, developing HTN during pregnancy significantly
increases the risk of future cardiovascular disease5,6. Studies show that in women
diagnosed with hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (HDP) the risk of developing
later CVD is 1.5-2 times higher than in normotensive pregnancies (REF
Oliver-William, et al BMC Med 2022). The risk of
cardiovascular disease is increased in a dose‑response manner-by approximately
200% to 300% among women with more severe hypertensive disorders of pregnancy,
particularly pre‑eclampsia5,6.
Interestingly, though, 10% to 40% of women with normotensive pregnancies
exhibited HTN in the postpartum period5,7-10; This evidence highlights pregnancy as a
“window” into a woman’s future cardiovascular health11.
1.2.
What are Gestational HTN and Postpartum HTN?
Blood Pressure (BP) is defined as the
pressure exerted in the arterial system. Systolic and diastolic blood pressures
represent the pressure the blood exerts on the walls of the arterial
vasculature during cardiac ventricular contraction and relaxation,
respectively. Although BP is a non-invasive measure and easy to acquire vital
signs, it is an important marker of cardiovascular health12-14. The American Heart
Association and the American College of Cardiology classify specific BP levels
into the following categories: Normal, elevated or hypertensive, with Stages 1
to Severe or a hypertensive emergency12,13. These agencies define HTN as: Stage 1 HTN,
a systolic blood pressure between 130 mmHg to 139 mmHg or a diastolic blood
pressure between 80 mmHg to 89 mmHg; Stage 2 HTN, a systolic blood pressure ≥140 mmHg or a diastolic blood pressure ≥90 mmHg12,13.
Due to the physiological changes
during pregnancy, especially of the cardiovascular system, the staging of blood
pressure is slightly different. During the three trimesters of pregnancy, as
well as the “fourth trimester” or 1-12 weeks postpartum, HTN is classified as
systolic blood pressure ≥140 mmHg or a diastolic
blood pressure of ≥90 mmHg12,13,15,16. Additionally,
obstetric providers will stage the HTN diagnosis based on when it occurred
during gestation. Therefore, HTN <20 weeks of gestation is considered
chronic HTN, whereas HTN ≥20 weeks of gestation
is classified as gestational HTN or preeclampsia, depending on other symptoms17,18. After the
fourth trimester, the standard cutoffs
for adult HTN apply for HTN diagnosis12,13,15,16.
Studies note that 12% to 40% of women develop new HTN within the first 12
months after delivery, even if they had normal blood pressure during pregnancy8-10. However, based on the
standard HTN guidelines, many women develop HTN within 1 to 15 years postpartum5,17-21.
1.3.
Connection between Postpartum Hypertension and Maternal Environment
Women endure
significant cardiovascular, metabolic, hormonal and structural challenges
throughout nine months, all of which are stressful. It is suggested that the
nature of her pregnancy predicts her future health trajectory. Since pregnancy
provides a window into a woman’s future cardiovascular health, it is important
to understand how the maternal environment can influence her future health5,6,11,22. There are many
risk factors during pregnancy associated with future maternal CVD. For example,
risk factors for new-onset postpartum high blood pressure include
non-modifiable traits, such as genetics, race, age >35
years and delivery via cesarean, as well as modifiable traits such as high Body
Mass Index (BMI), high lipids, current or previous cigarette smoking, physical
activity levels and diet8,23-25.
Women with at least three risk factors had an even greater risk of developing
new-onset postpartum high blood pressure8. Importantly, governing bodies such as the
American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology, the American College of Sports
Medicine and the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics support lifestyle interventions,
such as exercise and diet, to improve outcomes before, during and after
pregnancy14,26-29.
Most interventions during pregnancy that
focus on improving current and future maternal and child health aim at exercise
and/or dietary lifestyle changes30-40. Although exercise during pregnancy is important, the
majority of these studies demonstrate that maternal nutrition should be the
primary focus and exercise secondary30-40. As such, many studies have focused on the influence of
maternal diet and the risk of HDP41-45. In addition, studies have focused on how maternal diet
can influence future maternal cardiovascular health22,30-40,46. Besides the focus on
decreased sodium intake, such as the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH)
and Mediterranean diets, studies also focus on the influence of protein sources
(i.e., animal, dairy, vegetable) during pregnancy and maternal blood pressure
outcomes25,47-50.
Therefore, research supports the
connection between maternal environment and future risk of CVD. Although there
are numerous non-modifiable risk factors, there are also modifiable ones that
can be adjusted during pregnancy to improve maternal future health. Typically,
interventions focus on either or both exercise and diet during pregnancy as an
opportunity to improve maternal health during and after the pregnancy. With
this in mind, the purpose of this review is to provide an overview of the
pathophysiology and clinical presentation of postpartum HTN, current treatments
and nutritional interventions, as well as a review of current literature on the
topic of maternal protein sources during pregnancy and postpartum HTN.
2. Clinical Manifestation and Pathophysiology
2.1. Clinical Manifestation
Although HTN affects one in three adults, of which at
least half are women, it usually presents with no symptoms and thus, is called the
“silent killer”12,13,51.
Almost half of the people, most of whom are women, with HTN are unaware of their
condition12,13,51.
For women in whom the symptoms are not silent, they will present with
cardiovascular, cerebrovascular, renal or other system clinical manifestations.
For cardiovascular manifestations, women may thus have clinically developed
coronary artery disease, dilated right ventricular dysfunction, left
ventricular hypertrophy and chronic heart failure, resulting in a low ejection
fraction or even a myocardial infarction (heart attack)52,53. Other women will
develop cerebrovascular conditions, but present with severe and/or frequent
headaches with unknown origin or a cerebrovascular event (stroke). For those
women who have renal manifestations associated with postpartum, HTN might
present with decreased renal function (i.e., creatinine, BUN), which can
ultimately lead to chronic kidney disease52,53. Other clinical manifestations of
postpartum HTN are peripheral artery disease and vision changes due to
retinopathy52,53.
It is important to realize that some women will not present with symptoms associated
with coronary artery disease, heart function, headaches, renal changes or
visual changes, even with these changes, until years later, when it culminates
in a change in their resting blood pressure52,53.
2.2. Pathophysiology
Although
underlying changes are occurring postpartum and initial postpartum hypertension
may not be measured until 1 to 15 years after delivery, the initial
pathophysiological changes are initiated during pregnancy. For example, women
who experience
HDP, such as gestational HTN, preeclampsia (HTN with proteinuria), have an increased
risk of future CVD5,7.
Furthermore, if HDP presents with other APOs, a woman’s risk of future CVD
increases 2-3 fold5,7,54.
However, some women who experience postpartum HTN had normal blood pressure
during pregnancy9-11.
This is thought to be related to underlying systemic inflammation during the
pregnancy that might not present with specific symptoms, such as blood pressure
changes in gestation55-57.
Sometimes, the underlying systemic inflammation will present with placental
ischemia or other placental abnormalities.
Whether
symptoms occur in pregnancy or not, the etiology is thought to be elevated
levels of circulating inflammatory markers, such as sFlt-155-57. Since sFlt-1 is anti-angiogenic, for instance,
elevated levels could lead to placental ischemia. Thus, even after the baby and
placenta are delivered, there is still underlying systemic inflammation (i.e., cytokines),
which leads to endothelial damage of smaller vessels of the eye, brain, cardiac
muscle and kidneys, which will then continue to worsen across the years until
another physiological insult occurs. Often, a woman will have another hormone
shift from another pregnancy or perimenopause, which further exacerbates the
system and presents as her first high blood pressure.
3. Current Treatments and Nutrition
Interventions
3.1. Current Treatments
Standard
treatments for postpartum HTN will be the same for any HTN and include regular
blood pressure monitoring16,17,56.
Pharmacological treatments are usually ACE Inhibitors (i.e., enalapril), beta-blockers
(i.e., labetalol), calcium channel blockers (i.e., nifedipine, amlodipine) and
potentially diuretics (i.e., furosemide)14,51-53. If these first-line medications do not
work, then a central alpha-2 adrenergic agonist (i.e., methyldopa, clonidine)
with diuretics (i.e., hydrochlorothiazide) may be initiated. In addition, medical
nutrition therapy provided by a dietitian is often recommended for long-term management
of HTN12,13,51.
3.2. Nutritional interventions
For nutrition interventions, the Academy of
Nutrition and Dietetics recommends adopting the DASH diet, Mediterranean diet
or something similar58.
The standard recommendations of the DASH diet always begin with decreasing
sodium intake to <1500 mg each day58-60. There
is a plethora of evidence-based nutrition practice guidelines for MNT in
individuals with HTN. The overall
nutritional recommendations for those with postpartum HTN will focus on a
balanced diet. For example, women should be educated on the appropriate
quantity and quality of protein sources from animal, vegetable and dairy
sources for each day and each meal. Next, she will also be counseled on how
many vegetables and fruits to consume each day and with each meal. They will
also be taught about sources and amounts of carbohydrates throughout the day.
Lastly, they need to know about unsaturated vs. saturated fats to consume each day and focus on mono-
and polyunsaturated fats.
4. Review of Literature
Knowing
that pregnancy is associated with increased systemic inflammation, we know that
pregnancy is a physiological stress test and is considered a window into a
woman’s future cardiovascular health. Thus, it is important to focus on
pregnancy as a critical time to positively influence a woman’s current and
future cardiovascular health. Importantly, modifiable factors such as diet
during pregnancy are influential on cardiovascular health as well. In addition
to limiting sodium intake, protein intake and specifically protein sources are
important for her cardiovascular health as well.
In general, the Academy of Nutrition
and Dietetics categorizes proteins as either animal, vegetable/plant or dairy
sources61-63.
Within each of these categories, there are different food components. For
instance, dairy proteins can come from sources such as yogurt, milk, cheese and
cottage cheese61-63.
Vegetable/plant proteins can be sub-categorized as either legume (i.e., beans,
split peas, lentils, soy) or nuts and seeds (i.e., walnuts, almonds, chia
seeds, pumpkin seeds, pistachios, cashews and peanuts)61-63. Lastly, animal
protein is subcategorized as either from seafood/fish components (i.e., salmon,
tuna, cod, shrimp, mackerel, lobster, catfish) or meat/poultry/eggs (i.e., lean
cuts of beef, lamb, goat, pork loin, skinless chicken and turkey, quail and
duck) 61-63.
Importantly, there are differences in
protein digestibility and amino acid profiles between these protein sources.
To date, there are only four studies
that have examined the potential influence of the source of proteins during
pregnancy on the occurrence of future postpartum hypertension. The Norwegian MoBa
study assessed pregnant women’s diet around 22 weeks of gestation via a Food
Frequency Questionnaire (FFQ)47.
The FFQ assessed proteins as either from plants, dairy, eggs, seafood or other
animal meats. They then assessed their recorded blood pressures about 10 years
postpartum, as well as whether they were taking hypertensive medications and
for how long. They assessed a total of 59,967 pregnant women; of these women, 1,480
had developed HTN requiring medications by 10 years postpartum, finding that
animal protein, specifically red meat, during pregnancy had a positive
association with developing HTN by 10 years postpartum. They also found that consumption
of protein from fatty fish, such as salmon, during pregnancy had a negative
association with developing HTN by 10 years postpartum. Similarly, maternal
consumption of dairy protein, specifically milk and yogurt, during pregnancy had
a negative association with developing HTN by 10 years postpartum.
Interestingly, they found no association between plant protein intake during
pregnancy and the occurrence of postpartum HTN47. However, the leanness of the protein was not
considered in the analysis.
Secondly, another analysis within the
MoBa study by Egeland et al. assessed women via a FFQ at about 22 weeks of gestation48. The FFQ assessed
proteins as either from plants, dairy (and supplements of calcium and
magnesium), eggs, seafood and other animal meats, as well as the low and high-sodium/potassium
foods. They then assessed women’s EHRs for their blood pressure at 10 years
postpartum, as well as whether they were taking hypertensive medications and
for how long. They assessed a total of 56,646 pregnant women; of these women, 1,039
had developed HTN requiring medications by 10 years postpartum. Egeland et al.
found that postpartum HTN is associated with low calcium intake and foods with
high sodium/potassium foods48.
The third related study was conducted
in Denmark using a large cohort study methodology again. Women were assessed
via a FFQ at about 25 weeks of gestation49. The FFQ assessed proteins as either from fish-poultry
vegetarians (vegetarians who consume dairy
products and eggs), Lacto/Ovo-veg, Vegans or Omnivores. They also assessed
women’s EHRs for their blood pressure about 10 years postpartum, as well as
whether they were taking hypertensive medications and for how long. They
assessed a total of 65,872 pregnant women, finding outcomes like those of Oyen et al. They noted omnivores were less likely to
have developed postpartum HTN than vegans49. This study suggests that the amount of
protein matters, especially when combined with micronutrient deficiencies.
Lastly,
a smaller study by May et al.50, which is a randomized
controlled trial focused on supervised exercise during pregnancy, assessed
women via the ASA24 online 24-hr dietary recall at about 16 weeks of gestation.
The dietary recall assessed dietary protein intake from plants, dairy, eggs, seafood
and meats, as well as micronutrient intake levels. They also assessed the subject’s
recorded blood pressure postpartum. They assessed a total of 65 pregnant women.
May et al. also found outcomes like Oyen et al. They noted protein source, as well as
sodium and saturated fat levels, predicted maternal blood pressure64.
5. Conclusion
Overall, these studies demonstrate that
the protein source during pregnancy is related to the pregnant woman’s future
cardiovascular health. Thus, pregnant women may need to focus on dairy and lean
animal protein. Importantly, women should ensure they have appropriate levels
of sodium and saturated fat according to recommended levels. As other studies
demonstrate, improving maternal health will improve future cardiovascular
health. Research suggests that appropriate levels of dairy and lean animal
proteins during pregnancy can be helpful for her future cardiovascular health.
6. Funding: This research was supported by internal funds from ECU (PI: Linda May).
7. References