6360abefb0d6371309cc9857
Abstract
A recent article on the characteristics of the blood present on the Turin Shroud (or Holy Shroud) has distinguished the blood into the following categories: Type A, B and C.
Type A blood, consisting of microcytes, has been classified as shed during the crucifixion or after the death of Jesus, while Type B blood has been referred to as blood coagulated on the skin following the blood drippings when Jesus was still alive during the Passion. On the other hand, Type C blood has not been well identified due to the lack of samples to analyze adequately.
Subsequent analyses have instead allowed us to characterize this Type C blood better consisting of erythrocytes with dimensions slightly smaller than those of human blood. This is purported to be the blood Jesus exuded during the agony of Gethsemane. The Gospel of Luke [22:44] describes a clear case of hematidrosis, a condition in which Jesus sweated blood so profusely that it dripped to the ground.
This article provides a detailed analysis of experimental findings and explains why the hypothesis that Type C blood is linked to Jesus’ Hematidrosis in Gethsemane is plausible.
Keywords: Turn Shroud; Resurrection; Bloodstains; Hematidrosis; Erythrocytes; Osmolarity; Hypotonic solutions; Macrocytosis
Introduction
The
TS (Turin Shroud or Holy Shroud) is one of history's most studied and debated
religious Relics1-6. It is a handcrafted linen textile woven in a 3:1
herringbone twill pattern, measuring approximately 4.4 meters in length and 1.1
meters in width. The fabric bears the full-length, front and dorsal images of a
human figure, inexplicably impressed upon the cloth. This figure displays
wounds consistent with those of a man who underwent severe torture and
crucifixion, aligning with descriptions found in the CHB (Christian Holy Bible)
regarding the Passion and Death of Jesus, (Figure 1).
Throughout history, the TS has been venerated as a sacred relic, with records tracing its presence in different locations across centuries. Pope Julius II (1443–1513) officially recognized it as an object of adoration7, cementing its significance within Christianity. Historical analyses suggest that the TS may have been in Byzantium before the Sack of Constantinople (1204) and later made its way to Chambéry, France, before finally being housed in Turin, Italy, where it remains. Byzantine coins8 from as early as the 7th century depict facial features strikingly similar to those on the TS, fueling speculation that the Relic was known and revered long before its documented appearance in Western Europe.
Despite its historical and religious significance, the authenticity of the TS has been the subject of intense scientific scrutiny. One of the most controversial aspects of its study revolves around radiocarbon dating tests conducted in 1988, which placed the cloth’s origin between 1260 and 1390 AD9 - suggesting it was a medieval production rather than a 1st-century artifact.
However,
this conclusion has been highly contested due to probable contamination,
especially from environmental factors10-14.
Some15,16 have argued that selective
radioactivity could have biased the radiocarbon results, with hypotheses
linking the anomaly to the Resurrection of Jesus Christ.
Figure 1: Face of Jesus
Christ on the TS. The first Author added positive bloodstains to the negative
image
Beyond
radiocarbon dating, the TS exhibits unique physical and chemical properties
that challenge conventional explanations. Studies on Beta radioactivity and
fluorescence in the bloodstains16
suggest that the blood on the cloth interacted with energy-light in unusual
ways, hinting at an extraordinary event that affected the fabric.
Additionally,
forensic examinations17-20 confirm
the presence of liquid blood with no smearing, meaning the body was not moved
or manipulated after bleeding onto the cloth. Strikingly, there is no evidence
of putrefaction, an anomaly that remains scientifically unexplained and raises
further questions about the nature of the image formation.
Recent
studies17-20 have also explored the
concept of “material transparency” concerning the TS, examining how its fibers
interact with energy-light. Moreover, investigations into the bloodstains
provide further insights, reinforcing that the blood is consistent with wounds
caused by flogging, crucifixion and piercing by a sharp object paralleling the
CHB account of Jesus' Passion.
As
scientific inquiry continues, the TS remains an unparalleled mystery,
straddling the realms of faith, history and science. Whether viewed as a holy
Relic or an unresolved enigma, the TS continues to captivate scholars,
theologians and scientists alike - its secrets still waiting to be fully
uncovered.
This
article will also introduce an intriguing aspect: the presence of blood even
before the scourging and the crucifixion, as described in Luke [22:44], which
recounts Jesus’ sweating drops of blood in Gethsemane - a phenomenon known as
hematidrosis induced by extreme stress. Studying blood traces on the TS may
provide further clues about this rare but documented medical condition,
offering an additional potential link between the CHB narrative and forensic
analysis.
Summary of physical conditions of jesus
during passion
The physical
suffering endured by Jesus Christ during His Passion, crucifixion and
entombment is among the most extensively studied aspects of His life, both from
a theological and forensic perspective.
CHB accounts,
historical records and modern scientific analyses - especially those related to
the TS - offer profound insights into His physiological state during these
final moments. This summary synthesizes existing research, tracing Jesus'
suffering from the Last Supper to His burial in the Sepulcher, with a
particular focus on the novel insights provided by the TS regarding His
post-mortem condition and departure from the Relic, estimated to have occurred
30 to 40 hours after death16-19.
The Agony in
Gethsemane: Extreme Stress and Hematidrosis
During the Last Supper, Jesus began
to experience a heart condition (referred to as crepacuore in Italian), triggered by the psychological stress of
being near Judas, the traitor. Later that night, in the
Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus underwent an intense emotional and physiological
crisis. According to Luke [22:44], He suffered hematidrosis, a rare condition
in which extreme stress causes blood vessels in the sweat glands to rupture,
leading to blood-tinged perspiration. This rare but documented phenomenon21,22 indicates severe psychological distress, which weakened Jesus
before His subsequent physical torments.
The profound psychological stress
Jesus experienced in Gethsemane was driven by multiple factors. He faced the
impending separation from God the Father and the immense burden of bearing the
world's sins on His human psyche. His anguish intensified with the realization
that His suffering would be in vain for many who would ultimately reject Him.
This deep awareness, combined with overwhelming emotional and physiological
strain, contributed to the extreme distress He endured.
Let us not forget, in the Garden of
Gethsemane, Jesus, with His foreknowledge, knew that He would undergo an
extremely brutal pre-crucifixion scourging and that He - God- was destined to
be crucified and humiliated with a punishment deemed dishonorable for even
convicted Roman murderers.
One must also try to imagine His
pain in knowing the gut-wrenching anguish His beloved Co-Redemptrix Mother (a
helper in the Redemption) would experience in witnessing all of this.
Such factors led God-Incarnate to
simultaneously reach the apex of His anguish while also displaying the greatest
evidence of His humanity, His sweating blood as He prayed to His Father,
pleading to be relieved from the most pitiable of pain He was to endure in
atoning for the sins of humanity.
The cardiac event that had already
begun reached its apex in these moments as the Son, while pleading for grace,
subordinated Himself to His Father's will.
Arrest, Beatings and Mockery: Early Physical
Trauma
Following His arrest, Jesus endured
repeated beatings, blows to the face and psychological humiliation at the hands
of the Jewish authorities and Roman soldiers. The TS reveals injuries
consistent with these accounts, including swelling of the face, a broken nasal
cartilage and contusions on the cheeks. These injuries likely resulted in blood
loss and early dehydration, exacerbating His deteriorating condition.
The Scourging: Brutality of Roman Flagellation
Roman flogging was an exceptionally
brutal form of punishment. The TS shows over 370 wounds, consistent with those
inflicted by more than one kind of flagrum (Roman whip with multiple leather
thongs embedded with metal or bone fragments). This scourging caused deep
lacerations, muscle damage and severe blood loss, leading to hypovolemic shock-a
life-threatening condition resulting from substantial blood depletion. The
physical toll of the flogging alone would have left Jesus in excruciating pain,
extreme weakness and near collapse.
The Crown of Thorns: Additional Blood Loss and
Neurological Pain
Unlike traditional depictions, Roman
crucifixion did not typically involve a crown of thorns. However, the CHB
records Jesus' coronation with thorns as a historical event. It was an act of
mockery by Roman soldiers. For Christians, it symbolizes His coronation as the
King of Redeeming Sorrows.
The TS shows evidence of puncture
wounds on the forehead, temples and nape, corresponding to a circular band
probably composed of three rings of thorn branches of the type Rhamnus
Lycioides (a species of hawthorn).
These injuries would have caused
profuse bleeding due to the vascularity of the scalp, as well as trigeminal
nerve pain, producing an excruciating burning sensation.
The Carrying of the Cross: Falls and Shoulder
Trauma
Jesus was forced to carry His cross,
as indicated by the TS, which shows deep abrasions on both shoulders,
suggesting He bore the weight of a full wooden cross.
Tradition and physical evidence from
the TS, including a right shoulder dislocation and knee contusions, indicate
that He felt multiple times. These repeated falls likely further weakened His
body and may have caused additional internal bleeding23.
Crucifixion: Extreme Pain
Crucifixion was a prolonged form of
execution designed to induce a slow death through exhaustion and excruciating
pain with muscle spasms (tonic and clonic contractions). The TS provides
forensic evidence of nail wounds in the hands and feet; in particular, the nail
exit on the carpo-metacarpal area of the left hand is evident.
Already severely weakened by the
flagellation and the resulting hypovolemia (insufficient blood quantity), Jesus
likely suffered from hypoxemia (insufficient oxygenation). This condition was
caused, in part, by microcytic red blood cells, which had shrunk due to the
accumulation of urea in the blood that His kidneys-damaged by the flagellation-could
no longer filter properly.
The wound in His right side,
corresponding to the CHB narrative of a spear inflicted by a Roman soldier
[John 19:34], confirmed Jesus’ death. The TS shows a flow of blood mixed with a
watery fluid (serum), suggesting a hemothorax with hemopericardium. This
medical evidence is consistent with current forensic interpretations of death
by crucifixion.
The Burial and the Mystery of the TS
The body of
Jesus was taken down from the cross and wrapped in a linen cloth, the TS,
according to Jewish funeral customs. Forensic studies of the bloodstains from
the TS reveal intact rings of blood serum1,
indicating that the blood remained liquid and unaltered. Furthermore, the
absence of signs of putrefaction suggests that the body of Jesus did not
undergo the typical decomposition that begins about 40 hours after death18,19.
A particularly
mysterious aspect of the TS is the absence of smearing in the still-liquid
bloodstains, making Jesus' exit from the cloth-occurring 30 to 40 hours after
His death-scientifically inexplicable19.
The most reliable hypothesis is that this extraordinary occurrence corresponds
to the Resurrection of Jesus Christ18,19.
The image on the cloth was formed through an unknown process, seemingly linked
to a sudden burst of energy-light. This phenomenon resembles the Holy Fire24, a miraculous event occurring annually in the
Holy Sepulcher Basilica in Jerusalem.
The testimony on the
TS of Redemption and Resurrection
The immense
physical suffering endured by Jesus Christ, compounded by the moral anguish of
humiliation as documented in the CHB and supported by the forensic evidence of
the TS, represents perhaps the most intense form of human agony recorded in
history.
The Passion of
Jesus involved extreme psychological stress, repeated beatings, severe
hypovolemia, hypoxemia and multiple neuralgia, which, together with other
pathologies, led to death on the cross by cardiac tamponade.
The enigmatic
qualities of the TS, particularly the properties of blood and the inexplicable
formation of the image, continue to defy scientific explanations and can only
be explained by reference to a miracle connected to the Resurrection19.
Whether the TS
is viewed as a scientific or historical document or religious testament, the
study of the Passion of Jesus through forensic, medical, scientific and
theological lenses offers profound insights into the suffering freely endured
by Jesus for the redemption of humankind.
Hematidrosis described by evangelist luke
The phenomenon
described in Luke [22:44] where Jesus, in the Garden of Gethsemane, is said to
have sweated drops of blood, has long been a subject of theological and medical
inquiry. The passage, written in Greek, states: “καὶ γενόμενος ἐν ἀγωνίᾳ ἐκτενέστερον
προσηύχετο. ἐγένετο δὲ ὁ ἱδρὼς αὐτοῦ ὡσεὶ θρόμβοι αἵματος καταβαίνοντες ἐπὶ τὴν
γῆν.”
That, translated in English is: "And being in an agony he prayed more
earnestly. And his sweat became as it were great drops of blood falling down to
the ground."
This description
has often been debated-whether Luke intended it as a literal medical condition
or a figurative expression of Jesus’ extreme distress. However, modern medicine
confirms21,22 that hematidrosis is a
real, though rare, physiological condition, lending credibility to the literal
interpretation of Luke’s account, (Figure 2).
Figure 2: On the top, hematidrosis of Jesus in the Gethsemane
(Taisten-Tabernakelbildstock 04 - GNU FDL). On the bottom is a real example of
hematidrosis22
Medical Explanation
of Hematidrosis
Hematidrosis,
sometimes called blood sweat, is a rare disorder that occurs under conditions
of extreme physical or emotional stress. It results from intense
neurovegetative stimulation, which causes:
·
Dilation and increased permeability of blood vessels
surrounding the sweat glands.
·
Rupture of capillaries, leading to leakage of red
blood cells into the sweat ducts.
·
Mixing of blood with perspiration, which then
appears as red-tinged sweat.
Cases of
hematidrosis have been reported in individuals undergoing severe fear, extreme
stress or deep psychological anguish-consistent with the state of agony Jesus
experienced before His arrest and crucifixion. The extreme anxiety and distress
He endured would have triggered a massive autonomic nervous system response,
leading to this rare but scientifically documented condition.
Theological and
Linguistic Analysis of Luke [22:44]
Luke, being a
physician (Colossians [4:14]), was likely aware of medical conditions and their
descriptions. His use of ὡσεὶ θρόμβοι αἵματος (hōsei thromboi haimatos, “as it
were great drops of blood”, literally “clots of blood”) suggests that he was
describing a literal phenomenon rather than a mere metaphor for extreme
anguish.
The phrase ὡσεὶ
("as it were") could indicate either similarity or an actual
occurrence, but given the known existence of hematidrosis, many scholars argue
that Luke intended to describe an actual, physiological event.
Furthermore, the
phrase ἐν ἀγωνίᾳ (en agonia, “being in agony”) highlights the extreme emotional
torment Jesus endured. The word ἀγωνία (agonia), from which the English term
agony derives, conveys an intense struggle, often associated with mortal fear
or extreme mental distress. This aligns with the physiological triggers of
hematidrosis.
It is also
significant that Luke indicates that these drops of blood καταβαίνοντες ἐπὶ τὴν
γῆν “fell to the ground.” So, we must assume that it was a very intense
hematidrosis that was not limited to a simple sweating of blood on the face but
so realistic and intense that even drops of blood fell to the ground.
Significance of
Hematidrosis in the Passion Narrative
The presence of hematidrosis in Jesus' Passion has profound medical,
theological and symbolic implications.
· Medically, it indicates that Jesus' suffering began long before the
Passion. His body was already in a weakened and dehydrated state even before
His scourging and crucifixion, intensifying His overall physical burden.
· Theologically, it fulfills prophetic descriptions of the Messiah's
suffering (Isaiah [53:3-5]), reinforcing that Jesus bore extreme anguish even
before His arrest.
· Symbolically, the presence of blood before the actual shedding of blood
on the cross emphasizes the total sacrifice of Jesus-not just in death, but in
His profound suffering. His suffering began even before His arrest, as He shed
blood in Gethsemane and continued as He endured immense physical and emotional
torment leading to His crucifixion.
Jesus’ Hematidrosis
in the Gethsemane
Therefore,
Luke’s account of Jesus sweating blood in Gethsemane is not merely a poetic
expression of distress but an actual medical condition known as hematidrosis.
The intense psychological agony preceding His Passion was so extreme that it
triggered a rare but documented physiological response.
This phenomenon
confirms the physical toll of Jesus' suffering and provides deeper insight into
the immense burden He bore before His crucifixion, making the Passion narrative
even more profound from both a medical and theological perspective.
Ref.16
provides a detailed description of the samples that were analyzed to study the
different blood types.
(Figure 3) illustrates
the sampled areas and the types of sampling considered in this article. Below
is a brief description of these samples.
·
Point 1
corresponds to STuRP (Shroud of Turin Research Project) sticky tape 1EB put in
contact with the calf of the TS dorsal image.
·
Point 2
corresponds to STuRP sticky tape 1HB put in contact with the feet of the TS
dorsal image.
·
Point 3
corresponds to STuRP sticky tape 3EF put in contact with the wrist of the TS
frontal image.
·
Point 4
corresponds to STuRP sticky tapes 3AF put in contact with the finger of the TS
frontal image.
·
Area e
corresponds to the dust vacuumed from the back of the TS at the hands' area.
·
Area f
corresponds to the dust vacuumed from the back of the TS at the face area.
·
Area g
corresponds to the dust vacuumed from the back of the TS at the feet area,
dorsal image.
·
Area h
corresponds to the dust vacuumed from the back of the TS at the glutei and
legs, dorsal image.
·
Area i
corresponds to the dust vacuumed from the back of the TS in correspondence with
the C14/1988 area which, being in a corner, also collected dust coming from the
surface of the TS in correspondence with the legs and feet of the frontal
image.
Figure 3: sampled areas of the TS and
types of sampling considered in this article. The letters e, f, g, h, i
indicate the areas where the dust was vacuumed from the back of the Relic,
while the numbers 1-4 indicate the areas where the samples were taken using
sticky tapes
The first Author initially documented the samples
using an Olympus Zoom stereomicroscope. Then, the samples were analyzed with
optical, phase contrast and petrographic (or polarizing) microscopes in
reflected and transmitted, visible and UV light with magnifications up to
1500x.
Further analyses were performed with SEM (Scanning
Electron Microscope), ESEM (Environmental Scanning Electron Microscope) and
SEM-FEG (Field Emission Gun). Additionally, Raman analysis was conducted to
detect hemoglobin, a key component characteristic of blood. The element weight
percentages of the particles in question were determined via XRF-EDS (Energy
Dispersive X-ray Fluorescence Analysis), also called EDX (Energy dispersive
X-ray spectroscopy).
It is immediately observed that, although the sampling
from the TS was not extensive due to the limitations posed by Turin
Authorities, it appears to be sufficiently distributed across the entire area
of the Relic. This distribution allows for some preliminary conclusions
regarding the extent to which the single microscopic types of the material
analyzed are more widely distributed or more localized in specific areas.
Three different types
of blood detected
Ref.16
recently distinguished three different types of blood coming from the TS, they
are the following.
Type A blood
It consists of numerous orange-red particles that both
adhere to the TS linen fibers and are isolated in the tape’s adhesive. These
rounded discoidal particles appear like a donut with central concavity, (Figure 4) and it is very similar to
that of ordinary human erythrocytes, (Figure 5) on the top. This Type A blood is very similar to that
reported in Ref.25.
These particles of Type A blood evoke microcytes.
While human blood cells typically measure 7-8 micrometers, these particles
range from 0.3 to 2 micrometers, with 0.7 micrometers being most common.
Therefore, one can suppose these particles are microcytes derived from
erythrocytes of uncoagulated blood that underwent strong shrinkage. Given that
Jesus was suffering from very high uremia due to the flagellation which
probably induced kidney failure, this microcytic anemia suggests the extreme
difficulties He had in exchanging oxygen (hypoxemia). The high levels of creatinine detected in this Type A
blood can be easily explained by this supposed kidney failure. Type A blood
suggests its identification with post-mortem blood or with blood dripped in the
last moments of life on the cross.
This Type A blood is very particular because, unlike
common blood, it shows a red-orange fluorescence when observed under
ultraviolet light and a notable Beta radioactivity (i.e., electron emission).
This phenomenon will require further analysis in the future as it is
challenging to explain, especially when considering blood samples that are two
millennia old.
Figure 4: Examples of microcytes of Type A
blood coming from sticky tape 3EF
Figure 5: Examples of common human blood erythrocytes on the
top and echinocytes with macrocytes on the bottom
Type B blood
It was prevalently found in Areas f and h of (Figure 3) and consists of compact, but
brittle, sherds of crusts of a darker color than Type A blood, (Figure 6). It is rarer than Type A
blood and, therefore, less easy to characterize.
Its element composition is compatible with that of
blood; its size is up to a tenth of a millimeter and it has shapes that are not
rounded, but its edges suggest previous fragmentations of larger particles.
Other smaller sherds, with sizes of a few micrometers, have also been observed
in 2, 3 and 4 sticky tapes of (Figure
3).
Figure 6: Example of Type B blood (Sample
GF-h18)
This type of blood does not show directly, with an
optical microscope, the typical microstructures of the red blood cells found in
Type A blood.
This fact leads one to think that it can be classified
as pre-mortem blood that coagulated on the skin from open wounds while Jesus
was still alive. Therefore, it was not mixed with the anti-putrid aromatics
later used for the burial of the corpse.
Similarly to common blood and unlike Type A, Type B
blood is not fluorescent when observed in the ultraviolet and does not show
Beta radioactivity. However, it seems to emit Gamma radiation (i.e., photon
emission) whose measured level was close to the detector background noise. For
this reason, it will have to be analyzed in the future with more sensitive
instrumentation.
Type C blood
Ref.16
described Type C blood as a material consisting of very rare donut-shaped
particles found only in correspondence with the face area. Nevertheless, the
composition of these particles could not be determined because of a shortage of
material to test.
It reported that the particle diameter ranges from 2
to 5 micrometers and that this structure is compatible with that of
erythrocytes, (Figure 7).
Other erythrocytes classified as Type C
blood have recently been found through the SEM-FEG microscope in Area f
corresponding to the TS face, (Figure 8); they show elemental composition typical of common erythrocytes.
Figure 7: Type C blood (Sample GF-h18)
Figure 8: Recently detected erythrocyte
classified as Type C blood
G. Lucotte in Ref.26
also found erythrocytes that can be classified as Type C by studying a small
sticky tape (1.36 millimeters high and 614 micrometers wide) placed in contact
with the surroundings of a blood area of the TS face. In fact, many of them
are still well preserved and similar in form and elementary composition to that
reported in (Figure 8),
having variable dimensions from 2 to 7 micrometers.
Therefore, one can confirm that the Type C blood
consists of individual well-preserved erythrocytes of variable dimensions
between 2 and 7 micrometers, all coming from the TS Face area.
Evidence of jesus’
hematidrosis?
Ref.20 confirms what is reported in Ref.16 stating that subsequent analyses detected
the presence of other erythrocytes of dimensions slightly smaller than those
typical of human blood. It also hypothesizes that Type C blood was shed before
the uremia that shrank the erythrocytes due to Jesus’ flagellation.
Consequently, Ref.20 anticipated that it could be thought that these blood cells can be
directly correlated to the hematohidrosis manifested by Jesus in the
Gethsemane. Now, considering this hypothesis but, before continuing, it seems
necessary to make some additional observations.
Supposing that the
particles in question are erythrocytes, Ref.16 stated that
they did not coagulate because they were mixed with a hypothetical oily
substance, probably thinking of the oily mixture of aloe and myrrh mentioned in
the CHB [John 19:39].
This hypothesis, however, does not prevent thinking
that the possible oily mixture of aloe and myrrh was placed when the
erythrocytes under examination were already spread on the skin of the face and
that they were previously mixed with sweat, probably related to the
hematidrosis that occurred in Gethsemane.
Ref.16 also
stated that the larger dimensions of Type C erythrocytes compared to those of
the Type A blood could be explained by the fact that these particles were
scattered on the skin when Jesus was not yet in the final phase of the supposed
uremia and, therefore, the erythrocytes never completely shrank in size.
This observation seems correct but must be integrated
with some considerations on the swelling or shrinking of erythrocytes due to
the osmolarity (biophysical value in mOsm/l, milliosmoles per liter, which
expresses the number of particles, such as ions, present within a solution) of the liquids in which they are immersed.
It is known that, while isotonic solutions (like those
having a solution of 0.9% in weight of NaCl or those having a solution of 5% in
weight of glucose in fresh water) have the same concentration or osmolarity, of
particles present in solution in the erythrocytes and therefore, the same
osmotic pressure (that is between 240 and 340 mOsm/l, but frequently between
275 and 300 mOsm/l – meaning that there are 0.3x6.02223 = 1.823
molecules that do not pass through the erythrocytes membrane); hypotonic
solutions have lower concentrations of solutes and hypertonic solutions have a
higher concentration than that of erythrocytes.
Consequently, by osmosis, erythrocytes immersed in
hypotonic solutions tend to swell (macrocytosis, because water tends to move
inside the cell) becoming turgid until they burst, while erythrocytes immersed
in hypertonic solutions tend to shrink and wrinkle (microcytosis). (Figure 5) on the bottom is an example
of erythrocytes damaged by a different osmotic pressure of the liquid in which
they were immersed.
Since human sweat is a hypotonic (or hypoosmotic
liquid with a concentration between 80 and 180 mOsm/l) it tends to swell the
erythrocytes immersed in it, for example, during hematidrosis.
However, it is necessary to consider the probable
shrinkage of erythrocytes over time, also due to drying. In a similar case,
Ref.27 studied the possible shrinkage of erythrocytes due to drying in Egyptian
mummies and found erythrocytes
in the blood of a softened and rehydrated scalp of a mummy. After rehydration
(fresh water has an osmolarity of 2 a 5 mOsm/L), it detected rounded discoidal
elements with central concavity and a diameter of 4-5 micrometers.
Consequently, the erythrocyte of (Figure 8) which has a diameter of 6
micrometers, like the others found in similar samples (having variable diameter
from 2 to 7 micrometers), can be thought of as the result of an erythrocyte
that swelled (and therefore increased its diameter more than the 7-8 micrometers
typical of human blood) following immersion in a hypotonic liquid such as
sweat, but then it dried out over time and shrunk in size. The wrinkled surface
of the erythrocyte in question seems to confirm this drying out over time.
From these considerations,
one can suppose what happened to the erythrocytes of Type C blood. Ref.17 reports that the body of Jesus was not
completely washed but only cleansed. If the body had been completely washed it
would not be possible to think that any trace of the hematidrosis that occurred
in Gethsemane remained.
In agreement with Refs.16-20 one can assume that the erythrocytes of
the blood of Jesus of the HS remained unchanged until, during the flagellation the kidneys suffered a block and the
urea spread in the blood causing an acute microcytosis that reduced the
diameter of the erythrocytes even by a factor of 10.
However, the erythrocytes
related to hematidrosis, mixed with sweat which is a slightly hypotonic
solution, swelled without bursting, thus maintaining their discoid shape with
the central concavity.
Since the face of Jesus was
only cleansed, several erythrocytes due to hematidrosis remained on the skin of
the face, which was then smeared with an oily mixture of aloe and myrrh which
had the double function of shrinking these erythrocytes but also preserving
them well over time.
It is interesting here to
comment on the "second and most abundant class" of erythrocytes
mentioned in point 3 on page 150 of Ref.28,
consisting of red blood cells with a diameter of the order of 12.5 micrometers,
indicated by G. Lucotte as not of human but presumably of animal origin. The authors, on the basis of the analyses here performed, believe that
these macrocytes are of Type C blood due to prolonged immersion in a hypotonic
liquid such as sweat, thus confirming the supposed hematidrosis of Jesus suffered
in Gethsemane.
Because Type C blood erythrocytes come only
from the facial area of the TS and not from other areas, it does not seem
easy to contradict the hypothesis that the erythrocytes found in the Type C
blood are related to Jesus' hematidrosis in Gethsemane.
Conclusion
Recent
studies on the characteristics of the blood present on the TS16 have distinguished the blood into the
following categories: Type A, B and C based on the physical and morphological
characteristics of the particles analyzed.
That
article assumed that type A blood, composed of microcytes, is that which was
shed during the crucifixion or after the death of Jesus, while type B blood is
that which coagulated on the skin following the blood flowing down when Jesus
was still alive during the Passion.
Type
C blood, which was not identified with certainty in Ref.16 due to a lack of samples and was
preliminarily linked to hematidrosis in Ref.20,
has been analyzed in greater detail here, following the discovery of additional
specimens, also in agreement with the finding of Ref.28, that could aid in better identification.
The
erythrocytes of this type C blood are slightly smaller (diameter of 2-7
micrometers) than those of human blood (diameter of 7-8 micrometers) and very
well preserved in their shape and all come from the area of the TS face.
After
having considered the possible transformations of these erythrocytes following
their immersion in hypothetical human sweat which is a hypotonic solution
(variable from 80 to 180 mOsm/l), their subsequent treatment with an oily
mixture of aloe and myrrh during the preparation of the cadaver in the
sepulcher and their subsequent drying for two millennia, it does not seem easy
to contradict the hypothesis that this Type C blood can be correlated to the
blood exuded by Jesus during the agony of Gethsemane; in fact, the CHB [Luke
22:44] reports that Jesus endured an evident hematohidrosis. This caused an
intense sweating of blood that caused drops of blood to fall to the ground.
Future
studies based on new samples taken directly from the TS will be able to confirm
the hypothesis formulated here, that supposed Type C blood was due to the
hematidrosis of Jesus in the Gethsemane.
If this hypothesis is confirmed as the authors
suppose, even in the present study concerning the TS, the most important Relic
of Christianity, they observe how the study of the characteristics of Type C
blood brings the scientific results closer to those described in the CHB
confirming the strict relations between science and faith.
Acknowledgments
The
authors thanks Jacopo
Nava, technician of the "Geosciences-GEO” Research Laboratories of the
University of Padua for the microanalyses performed and shown in (Figure 8).
The
first author heartily thanks the late Prof. Don Lieto Massignani, who highly
encouraged the writing of this paper and the Holy Spirit; he also thanks all
the institutions and scholars mentioned in Refs.16,19 and
related papers who provided him with material from the TS.
Ethical
statements
As more widely reported in Ref.19 the authors, belonging to the Christian Roman
Catholic religion, experienced a profound strengthening of faith through
scientific studies on the TS.
Funding
This
research too was supported by a religious group, reported in Ref.19
that entrusted the author with the analysis of the so-called "Padre Pio
handkerchief".
Conflicts
of interest
The
author declares no conflict of interest.
References
6. Wilson
J, Miller V. The Mysterious Shroud. Doubleday, London, UK 1991.
7. Garello
E. The Shroud and the Popes, Corsi Ed. Turin 1984.
11.
McAvoy T. On
Radiocarbon Dating of the Shroud of Turin. Int J Archaeol 2021;9(2):34-44.
14. Phillips
TJ. Shroud irradiated with neutrons? Nature 1989;337.
17.
Fanti G. Turin
Shroud: Medical Impossibility for a Medieval Work of Art. Annal Cas Rep Rev 2025;424.
21.
Maglie R, Caproni
M. A case of blood sweating: hematohidrosis syndrome. CMAJ 2017;189(42):E1314.
26.
Lucotte G. Red
Blood Cells on the Turin Shroud. J Hemato 2017;4(2):024.
27. Rabino-Massa
E, Chiarelli B, Sacerdote M, Focale C. Presence of red blood cells in the
tissues of Egyptian mummies. J Biol Res - Bulletin of the Italian Society of
Experimental Biology 1967:20.