Abstract
Preterm infants
undergo a highly critical and stressful intensive care process in neonatal
intensive care units (NICUs) to sustain life. During this period, they are
exposed daily to numerous repeated painful invasive procedures and the
associated stress. However, current knowledge regarding the long-term
consequences of early-life pain and stress exposure in preterm infants remains
limited, underscoring the need for further investigation.
The present study
aimed to investigate the effects of pain and stress induced by an experimental
model of repeated invasive procedures-designed to mimic the neonatal intensive
care experience of preterm infants-on early physical growth and motor
development, as well as on later behavioral outcomes and learning performance
in neonatal rats. A total of 16 neonatal Wistar albino rats were included in
this study. The experimental group (n = 8) was subjected to repeated invasive
procedures from postnatal day (PN) 1 to PN10. Specifically, ten invasive
stimulations were administered daily at 1-hour intervals using a sterile
24-gauge branula needle to the skin of the neck, forelimbs and thoracic region.
Early physical
development parameters-including body weight gain, timing of eye opening, ear
unfolding and tooth eruption-were assessed in both the intervention and control
groups. Motor reflex development (crawling, walking, cliff avoidance, grasping
reflex, righting reflex and other motor tests) was also evaluated. In later
life, behavioral performance, learning capacity, motor balance, pain responses
and brain histopathological findings were examined and compared between groups.
Neonatal rats that were not subjected to invasive procedures exhibited
significantly greater body weight gain compared to those exposed to repeated
interventions (p < 0.05). No significant differences were observed between
groups in terms of motor reflex development tests (p > 0.05).
In young adulthood,
rats exposed to repeated invasive procedures demonstrated increased fear- and
anxiety-related behaviors compared to controls. Additionally, attention,
learning and memory performance were significantly impaired in the intervention
group (p < 0.05). Social interaction levels were significantly higher in the
control group than in the intervention group during young adulthood (p <
0.05).
Rats exposed to
repeated invasive procedures showed delayed responses to painful stimuli and
exhibited increased pain tolerance compared to controls (p < 0.05).
Histopathological
evaluation in young adulthood revealed significantly higher numbers of
apoptotic cells in the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus, parietal cortex,
prefrontal cortex and retrosplenial cortex in the intervention group compared
to controls (p < 0.001).
In conclusion, the findings of this study indicate that pain-induced stress resulting
from repeated invasive procedures in preterm neonatal rats adversely affects
physical growth, motor development, behavioral outcomes and learning
performance.
Keywords: Preterm neonatal rats, Repeated invasive procedures,
Pain, stress, Anxiety, Physical development, Behavioral outcomes, Learning
performance
1. Introduction
According to
the World Health Organization, approximately 15 million infants are born
preterm each year worldwide and this number continues to rise1. Preterm infants particularly those born
between 24 and 32 weeks of gestation require intensive and specialized care in
neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) to survive. During this life-saving care
process, preterm infants are exposed daily to repeated procedural pain and the
associated stress. Although preterm infants possess the necessary nociceptive
circuitry to perceive pain, these systems are not yet fully functionally mature2,3. Infants born before 35 weeks of
gestation demonstrate central sensitization in response to repeated invasive
painful stimuli4-8. Neonatal pain
responses vary depending on gestational age, sleep–wake state and the intensity
and duration of the invasive procedure9,10.Clinicians
often face challenges in accurately recognizing and effectively managing pain
in preterm infants. Pharmacological treatments are not considered ideal for
routine pain management in this population11.
Although non-pharmacological strategies are recommended as first-line
approaches, invasive procedures in NICUs are frequently performed without
adequate supportive interventions12.
Stress hormones are
glucocorticoids that regulate gene transcription in both the body and the brain
(cortisol in humans and corticosterone in rodents)13. In physiologically immature
neonates, prolonged activation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis
may therefore lead to long-term alterations in hormonal (e.g., growth and
glucocorticoid regulation), physiological (e.g., metabolic and immune) and
behavioral systems (e.g., anxiety and depression)14,15.
Despite the high
number of invasive procedures required during their stay in the NICU, preterm
infants often exhibit lower-than-expected cortisol levels16. In an experimental
study, rat offspring exposed to prolonged maternal separation during early life
demonstrated reduced hippocampal glucocorticoid receptor expression and
increased production of corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF),
adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) and corticosterone in adulthood17. Prolonged stress
exposure in preterm infants has also been associated with alterations in
glucocorticoid receptor expression in the hippocampus and prefrontal cortex,
which may contribute to long-term structural and functional changes in the
brain18.
The neonatal brain
contains two particularly vulnerable cell populations: subplate neurons and
pre-oligodendrocytes. Pain-related stress in the neonatal period may disrupt
pre-oligodendrocytes cells that ensheath axons prior to differentiation into
myelin-producing oligodendrocytes thereby interfering with normal myelination19. Subplate neurons are
among the earliest-generated neurons in the mammalian cerebral cortex and
represent the first cortical neurons to receive excitatory synaptic input from
thalamic axons, forming transient connections between thalamic projections and
their ultimate cortical targets20-22.
During early
development, N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors play a critical role in pain
signal transmission. Compared to NR2B, the NR2A receptor subunit becomes
developmentally more active. Repeated procedural pain may induce excessive
glutamate release and calcium influx, leading to excitotoxicity and apoptosis
of subplate neurons23-25. The immature state of subplate neurons renders them particularly
vulnerable to reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, as well as to cytokines
released by activated microglia26-31. Procedural pain triggers both oxidative stress and inflammatory
responses, potentially impairing myelination processes32,33.
Procedural pain and
stress experienced in the NICU have been shown to be associated with abnormal
brain development in very preterm infants up to term-equivalent age34,35. Consistent with
these findings, animal models have demonstrated that both inflammatory pain and
repeated injections increase apoptosis in the neonatal rat brain36,37. Moreover, the
impact of neonatal pain-related stress appears to extend beyond early life,
influencing long-term neurodevelopmental outcomes34,38.
In a cohort study,
greater exposure to skin-breaking procedures in the NICU was associated with
reduced cortical gray matter thickness in 21 of 66 cerebral regions at 7 years
of age, predominantly affecting the frontal and parietal lobes39. In very preterm infants,
stress related to invasive pain has also been linked to alterations in
spontaneous brain activity at school age and was negatively correlated with
visual-perceptual abilities40.
Although advances
in neonatology have significantly improved survival rates among preterm
infants, more than one-quarter of survivors experience moderate to severe
neurodevelopmental impairments. In preterm infants, an imbalance between
pain-excitatory and inhibitory mechanisms results in increased nociceptive
signaling within the central nervous system, contributing to excitotoxicity,
oxidative stress and inflammation in vulnerable cell populations41.
During their NICU
stay, preterm infants are exposed to an average of approximately 10 invasive
and stressful procedures per day, amounting to nearly 200 painful procedures in
total. Other reports indicate that neonates in the NICU undergo between 7 and 17
painful procedures daily42,43. Furthermore, long-term cohort studies have shown that neonates exposed
to repeated painful stimuli exhibit significantly lower intelligence, motor
performance and behavioral regulation at school age compared to term-born peers44. Greater exposure to
invasive pain during the preterm period has also been associated with poorer
cognitive and motor outcomes, as well as increased anxiety- and depressive-like
behaviors later in life39,45,46.
In light of the
aforementioned literature, prolonged exposure to repeated procedural pain
appears to exert significant developmental effects on the neonatal brain.
Stress associated with neonatal pain may adversely influence brain maturation
and these neurodevelopmental consequences seem to persist throughout life.
The aim of the
present study was to investigate the effects of pain induced by repeated
invasive procedures in a preterm neonatal rat model on early physical growth
and motor reflex development, as well as on long-term pain tolerance responses,
motor coordination and cognitive functions.
2. Materials and Methods
Animals and experimental design; This study was conducted following approval
from the Dokuz Eylül University Animal Experiments Local Ethics Committee
(Protocol No: 09/2022). A total of 16 neonatal Wistar albino rats born to three
different dams were obtained from the Multidisciplinary Experimental Research
Laboratory of Dokuz Eylül University Faculty of Medicine.
Offspring from each
dam were randomly assigned to either the invasive intervention (experimental)
group or the non-intervention (control) group. Dams and their litters were
housed in standard rodent cages under controlled environmental conditions
(12-hour light/12-hour dark cycle, temperature 22-25°C, relative humidity 50-60%).
Dams were fed standard rodent pellet chow ad libitum.
Neonatal rats are
born weighing approximately 4-5 g. The first 10 postnatal days are considered
developmentally comparable to the premature period in humans. In rats,
postnatal days 1-21 correspond to the lactation period; days 32-48 represent
sexual maturation; days 49-70 correspond to adolescence; and after day 100,
rats are considered adults47.
Neonatal rats were
selected as the experimental model because the first 10 postnatal days reflect
a developmental stage comparable to prematurity in humans, thereby enabling
simulation of the clinical conditions experienced by preterm infants. In the
present study, behavioral, learning and memory assessments were conducted
between postnatal days 30 and 60, corresponding to the human
childhood/school-age developmental period.
The timeline of
repeated invasive procedures and the schedule of experimental assessments are
presented in (Figure 1):
2.1. Experimental groups and study design
Control group (no invasive intervention) (n = 8):
Offspring were separated from their
dams 10 times daily between postnatal days (PN) 1 and 10. No invasive
procedures were performed during these separations.
Experimental group (repeated invasive intervention)
(n = 8):
Offspring were separated from their dams 10 times daily between PN1 and PN10.
During each separation, invasive procedures were administered at 1-hour
intervals using a 24-gauge needle to three different skin regions (neck,
forelimb and thoracic area).
Figure 1: Timeline of Repeated
Invasive Procedures and Behavioral Assessments.
Repeated Invasive Procedure in Neonatal Rats;
Repeated invasive procedures were administered to neonatal rats beginning on
postnatal day 1. Offspring were separated from their dams and placed on a cloth
warmed to mimic maternal body temperature. Invasive stimulation was performed
at 1-hour intervals using a sterile 24-gauge branula needle inserted into the
skin of the neck, forelimb and thoracic regions (Figure 2). Each
procedure lasted approximately 1-2 minutes.
All procedures were conducted daily between
08:00 and 17:00 under standardized experimental conditions.
Figure 2: Repeated Invasive
Procedures in Neonatal Rats.
The experimental protocol was designed in
consideration of the average length of stay of preterm infants in neonatal
intensive care units48,49. During each session, three
invasive stimulations were administered to each neonatal rat, targeting three
different anatomical regions: the neck, forelimb and lateral thoracic wall.
Because the procedures were repeated 10 times
daily at 1-hour intervals, each offspring received a total of 30 invasive
stimulations per day. As the intervention period lasted for 10 consecutive
days, each neonatal rat was exposed to a total of 300 invasive procedures.
Given that one postnatal day in rats is
considered approximately equivalent to 19 human days, the 10-day intervention
period was assumed to simulate approximately 5–6 months of NICU exposure in a
preterm infant.
Invasive procedures were performed using a
sterile 24-gauge branula needle inserted subcutaneously. During handling,
offspring were touched using gloved hands and a clean cloth. Care was taken to
avoid skin injury and bleeding. If minor bleeding occurred at the intervention
site, it was gently cleaned with sterile cotton before the offspring were
returned to their dams. This precaution was taken to prevent the potential
development of cannibalistic behavior in the dams.
3. Assessment Methods of Repeated Invasive
Procedures in Preterm Neonatal Rats
3.1. Evaluation of early-life effects
· Body weight monitoring: Neonatal rats that
completed the first 24 hours after birth were considered postnatal day 1. Body
weights of both intervention and control groups were measured daily at the same
time to monitor weight gain.
· Assessment of physical development: Physical
developmental milestones were recorded in both groups, including ear unfolding
(detachment of the pinna from the head), fur development, eye opening, eruption
of incisors and transition to solid food.
· Assessment of motor reflex development: To evaluate the
potential effects of repeated invasive procedures on motor reflex development,
standardized motor reflex tests were performed according to previously
published protocols50,51. Assessments were conducted
once daily between postnatal days 3 and 18, between 09:00 and 12:00 a.m.
All motor tests were video-recorded and
independently scored by two researchers blinded to group allocation.
Beginning on postnatal day 3, the following
motor reflexes were evaluated: crawling, forelimb and hindlimb grasp reflex,
forelimb and hindlimb suspension, cliff avoidance, negative geotaxis, auditory
startle response, accelerated righting reflex and grip strength.
The timing of motor developmental assessments
was determined based on the literature (Figure 3).
Figure 3: Motor Reflex Tests in
Neonatal Rats and Their Time Schedule.
3.2. Evaluation of long-term effects
Assessment of Learning, Memory and Behavior;
To evaluate the long-term effects of repeated painful invasive procedures on
learning, memory and behavior, offspring were subjected to the open field test
(PN32-33), Y-maze test (PN35-38) and social interaction test (PN43-44).
Open Field Test: The open field test was
performed on postnatal days 32-33 to assess exploratory behavior and
anxiety-like responses following repeated painful interventions. The open field
test is widely used to evaluate both anxiety-related behavior and locomotor
activity.
Behavioral recordings and analyses were
conducted using the Noldus video tracking system (Figure 4). Reduced
time spent in the center of the arena and increased time spent in the periphery
or corners were considered indicators of anxiety-like behavior52,53.
Figure 4:
Open Field Test Arena.
Y-Maze Test: The Y-maze test was conducted on
postnatal days 35-38 to assess short-term memory, spatial exploration and
attention54. The apparatus consisted of three arms (15 cm arm
width × 50 cm arm length × 30 cm wall height) constructed from black
polypropylene.
In animals with intact prefrontal cortical
function, there is a natural tendency to explore a novel arm rather than
returning to previously visited arms.
During the training phase, one arm was closed
and each rat was allowed to explore the two open arms for 10 minutes daily at
the same time of day. On the test day (day 4), the previously closed arm was
opened and the number of entries into the novel and familiar arms, as well as
the time spent in each arm, were recorded over a 10-minute test period.
Behavioral data were recorded and analyzed using the Noldus
video tracking system. The maze was cleaned with 70% ethanol after each trial.
Time spent in arms A, B and C was calculated from the video recordings. The duration of time each rat spent
in arms A, B and C was calculated from the recordings (Figure 5).
Figure 5:
Y Maze Test Arena.
· Social Interaction Test: The social interaction test
was performed on postnatal days 43-44, approximately five weeks after repeated
invasive procedures55. The test arena (90 × 45.5
× 40 cm) was divided into three equal compartments using plexiglass walls (Figure
6). The apparatus consisted of a central chamber and two side chambers
accessible through sliding doors.
1.Prior to testing, stimulus rats of similar
age were habituated for two days (10 minutes per day) in small wire cages (20 ×
14 × 13 cm) placed within the test arena.
On the test day, the experimental rat was
initially placed in the central compartment with the doors closed and baseline
behavior was recorded for 5 minutes. After this period, an unfamiliar, same-sex
conspecific (previously habituated to the cage) was placed in a wire cage in
one of the side chambers, while an empty cage was placed in the opposite
chamber. The doors were then opened and the experimental rat’s behavior was
recorded for 10 minutes.
Following this phase, the experimental rat
was returned to the central chamber. A novel, same-sex unfamiliar rat was
placed in the previously empty cage and behavior was recorded for an additional
10 minutes after reopening the doors.
All behavioral recordings were performed and
analyzed using the Noldus video tracking system. The arena was cleaned with 70%
ethanol after each trial (Figure 6).
Figure 6:
Social interaction Test Arena.
3.3. Assessment of responses to noxious
stimuli
Hot Water Tail-Flick Test; The hot water
tail-flick test was performed on postnatal days 47–49 to evaluate thermal
nociceptive responses following repeated painful invasive procedures. All tests
were conducted between 10:00 and 13:00 to minimize circadian variability.
Each rat was gently restrained using a towel
and approximately 3–4 cm of the distal tail was immersed in a water bath
maintained at 52 ± 0.5°C. A stopwatch was activated at the moment of tail
immersion. The latency (in seconds) to tail withdrawal or flicking was recorded
as an index of thermal pain sensitivity56,57.
Formalin Test; The formalin test was
conducted on postnatal day 53 to assess responses to chemically induced
nociceptive stimulation. Prior to testing, rats were habituated to a
transparent plexiglass observation chamber for 30 minutes to reduce
novelty-induced stress.
To control for potential circadian influences
on nociceptive and analgesic sensitivity, all procedures were performed between
10:00 and 13:00. Each rat received a subcutaneous injection of 0.05 mL of 2.5%
formalin into the plantar surface of the left hind paw using a 24-gauge branula
needle. Immediately following injection, a stopwatch was started.
The number of paw withdrawals and licking
behaviors during the first 5 minutes following injection was recorded as
indicators of nociceptive response58,59. Behavioral scoring
was performed by an observer blinded to group allocation. To minimize data
loss, behavioral responses were video-recorded and independently monitored by
at least two observers.
Assessment of Balance and Motor Coordination;
Balance and motor coordination were evaluated on postnatal days 50–52 to
determine the effects of pain- and stress-related exposure on motor
performance. All assessments were conducted between 10:00 and 13:00.
For the motor balance test, a wooden beam
measuring 105 cm in length, 4 cm in width and 3 cm in height was elevated 80 cm
above the floor. One end of the beam was designated as the starting point,
while a platform containing the rat’s home cage was positioned at the opposite
end (Figure 7). A line was marked 20 cm from the starting point and the
rat was placed within this designated starting area, facing toward its home
cage.
The stopwatch was initiated immediately upon
placement of the rat. The time required for the rat to traverse the beam and
reach the home cage platform with all four paws was recorded as the latency to
completion60.
Figure 7:
Rat Motor Balance Test Bar and its Characteristics.
Brain Histopathological Evaluation; On
postnatal day 54, approximately eight weeks after repeated invasive procedures,
rats were anesthetized with ketamine (50 mg/kg) and xylazine (10 mg/kg) and
positioned supine on a surgical platform. Following sternotomy, the thoracic
cavity was opened.
While cardiac activity was maintained, the
right atrium was incised to allow blood drainage and 30–40 mL of physiological
saline was perfused through the left ventricle to remove circulating blood from
the vascular system and tissues. Subsequently, transcardial perfusion was
performed with 30-40 mL of 10% formaldehyde to achieve whole-body fixation.
After perfusion, craniotomy was performed and
the brain and cerebellum were removed en bloc. Histopathological evaluation
focused on the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus, parietal cortex and
prefrontal cortex.
Statistical Analysis; Statistical analyses
were performed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS)
software (version 24.0). Descriptive statistics were expressed as mean ±
standard deviation (SD).
Normality of data distribution was assessed
using the Shapiro–Wilk test. For comparisons between groups, the Kruskal–Wallis
test was used for non-parametric data and post hoc pairwise comparisons were
performed using the Mann–Whitney U test when appropriate. Independent-samples
t-tests were used to compare means between two groups when parametric
assumptions were met.
All models constructed for six variables
satisfied parametric assumptions. Statistical significance was defined as p
< 0.05.
4. Results
Body Weight Changes; Comparison of body
weight gain between the experimental and control groups demonstrated higher
weight gain in the control group between postnatal days (PN) 4 and 18. A
statistically significant difference in mean body weight between the groups was
observed on PN8 (p <0.05).
Although body weight gain remained higher in
the control group after PN18, statistical significance was no longer observed.
After PN40, the difference in body weight between the two groups was no longer
evident.
Assessment of Physical Development; Physical
developmental parameters, including timing of ear unfolding, separation of
toes, eruption of upper and lower incisors, fur development and eye opening,
were compared between the experimental and control groups. No statistically
significant differences were observed between groups for any of these
developmental milestones.
In-Cage Sibling Interaction Behavior; Offspring
exposed to repeated invasive procedures exhibited increased activity levels and
more aggressive and competitive behaviors toward both intervention-exposed and
non-exposed littermates within the cage environment. Prolonged fighting
episodes and dominance-related behaviors were more frequently observed in the
experimental group compared with controls.
Abnormal Vocalization; Abnormal vocalizations
were observed in rats exposed to repeated invasive procedures beginning on the
second and third days of the experiment when handled manually. Following
separation from their dams for interventions and motor testing, these animals produced
intense vocal sounds, showed escape-related reactions and increasingly
attempted to protect the intervention sites.
Notably, despite having unopened eyes during
this developmental period, intervention-exposed offspring demonstrated clear
protective responses toward the stimulated body regions.
Motor Reflex Development; Motor reflex
development was evaluated to determine the effects of repeated invasive
procedures. No significant differences were detected between experimental and
control groups in crawling onset, righting reflex, cliff avoidance, forelimb
and hindlimb grasp reflexes, forelimb and hindlimb suspension tests, walking
onset, grip strength, hind paw placement, auditory startle response, negative
geotaxis, eye opening time or accelerated righting reflex performance.
4.1. Learning, memory and behavioral
assessment results
Open Field Test; The open field test was
performed to evaluate the effects of repeated invasive procedures on
anxiety-like behavior and locomotor activity. The mean values, standard
deviations and p-values of open field test variables for the experimental and
control groups are presented in (Table 1).
According to the open field test results,
rats in the control group demonstrated a higher frequency of entries into the
central zone and spent significantly more time in the center compared with the
experimental group. Comparison of time spent in the central area revealed a
statistically significant difference between groups (p <0.05).
In contrast, rats exposed to repeated
invasive procedures showed a greater preference for the peripheral areas of the
open field arena.
Social Interaction Test; The social
interaction test was conducted on postnatal days 43–44 to assess the effects of
repeated invasive procedures on social behavior. Comparison of sociability and
social preference parameters demonstrated significantly higher sociability
scores in the control group compared with the experimental group (p <0.05) (Table
1).
Y-Maze Test; The Y-maze test was performed to
evaluate learning and memory performance. Rats in the control group exhibited
significantly higher numbers of entries into the novel arm and spent more time
in the novel arm compared with rats exposed to repeated invasive procedures (p <0.05).
Mean values, standard deviations and p-values
of Y-maze test variables according to study groups are presented in (Table 1).
Table 1: Learning, Memory and
Behavioral Assessment Outcomes in Experimental and Control Groups.
|
Tests |
Variables |
Control group (Mean ±SD) |
Experimental group (Mean±SD) |
P* |
|
Open Field |
Frequency of entering
the center |
7,7±5,5 |
4,8±2,8 |
0,034 |
|
Time spent at the
center (seconds) |
16,8±9,5 |
10,2±6,3 |
0,045 | |
|
Frequency of periphery entry |
5,7±5,5 |
6,6±2,9 |
0,356 | |
|
Peripheral presence time (seconds) |
287,1±9,4 |
332,8±6,3 |
0,250 | |
|
Social Interaction |
Social skills score |
0,32±0,3 |
0,18±0,26 |
0,043 |
|
Social preference score |
0,09±0,41 |
0,05±0,53 |
0,538 | |
|
Y Maze |
Time spent on the new
arm (sec.) |
275,9±114,9 |
169,3±150,1 |
0,032 |
|
New arm input count |
9,13±3,36 |
5,29±1,49 |
0,029 |
4.2.
Assessment of responses to painful
stimuli
Formalin
Test; The formalin test was performed
to compare nociceptive responses between rats exposed to repeated invasive
procedures and control animals. Rats in the experimental group exhibited fewer
hind paw withdrawal and licking behaviors following formalin injection compared
with the control group. Comparison of hind paw withdrawal counts revealed a
statistically significant difference between the groups (p <0.05) (Table 2).
Hot
Water Tail-Flick Test; The hot water
tail-flick test was conducted to evaluate responses to thermal nociceptive
stimulation. Rats exposed to repeated invasive procedures demonstrated longer
tail withdrawal latencies compared with control rats. Comparison of tail
withdrawal times between the two groups showed a statistically significant
difference (p < 0.05) (Table
2).
Table
2:
Results of the Formalin Test and Hot Water Tail-Flick Test.
|
Tests |
Variables |
Control group |
Experimental group |
P* |
|
Formalin |
Rear Leg Pull Count Median (Min-Max) |
36(23-56) |
29 (13-47) |
0,025 |
|
Hot Water Tail
Immersion |
Tail Pulling Time
(seconds) Average ± SS |
4,7 ±0,6 |
5,2 ± 0,3 |
0,033 |
*MWU -test
4.3.
Balance and motor coordination assessment results
The
effects of repeated invasive procedures on balance and motor coordination in
later life were evaluated in preterm neonatal rats. Rats in the control group
crossed the balance beam in a shorter time compared with rats in the
experimental group (Table 3).
Statistical
comparison between the two groups revealed a significant difference in
performance (p <0.05). In addition, rats in the experimental group were
observed to fall from the balance beam more frequently during testing.
Table
3:
Balance and Motor Coordination Test Results.
|
Motor Balance Test |
Control group |
Experimental group |
P* |
|
Time to Cross the Balance Bar (seconds) Average
± SS |
16,2 ±3,3 |
7,3 ± 0,9 |
0,003* |
*T -test
4.4. Brain histopathological
evaluation results
Histopathological
analyses were performed to evaluate brain regions associated with learning,
memory, behavior and pain processing following repeated invasive procedures.
The effects of repeated invasive interventions on apoptotic cell counts were
examined in the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus, parietal cortex and
prefrontal cortex.
Rats
exposed to repeated invasive procedures demonstrated higher numbers of
apoptotic cells in the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus, parietal cortex
and prefrontal cortex compared with control animals.
The
mean apoptotic cell counts, standard deviations and statistical comparisons
between the experimental and control groups are presented in (Table 4).
Representative histopathological images demonstrating apoptotic neuron density
in the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus, parietal cortex and prefrontal
cortex are shown in (Figure 8).
Table
4:
Apoptotic Cell Counts in Different Brain Regions.
|
Brain Region |
Control group (Mean±SD) |
Experimental group (Mean±SD) |
P* |
|
Hippocampus CA 1 apoptotic cell numbers |
1,33±0,56 |
10,83±4,3 |
0,001 |
|
Gyrus dentatus apoptotic cell numbers |
2,28±0,80 |
13,61±8,06 |
0,001 |
|
Parietal cortex apoptotic cell numbers |
10,28 ±5,11 |
26,01 ±12,43 |
0,001 |
|
Prefrontal cortex apoptotic cell numbers |
6,67 ±2,28 |
14,83 ±6,29 |
0,001 |
*T test
Figure
8:
Histopathological Evaluation of Brain Regions and Apoptotic Cells.
5.
Discussion
Effects
on Body Weight Gain; In the present study, pain- and stress-related exposure
caused by repeated invasive procedures negatively affected body weight gain in
preterm neonatal rats. Offspring exposed to repeated interventions exhibited
lower weight gain compared with controls, with the difference reaching
statistical significance particularly on postnatal day 8 (p <0.05). However,
during later developmental stages when invasive procedures were discontinued,
the difference in body weight gradually diminished and was no longer
statistically significant. These findings are consistent with the study
conducted by Anand et al., in which repeated invasive stimulation was
associated with reduced weight gain in neonatal rats61. Our results suggest that repeated
procedural pain and stress experienced during early life may contribute to
growth impairment, a condition that may also be relevant to preterm infants
exposed to frequent invasive procedures in neonatal intensive care units.
Effects
on Physical Development; Repeated invasive procedures and the associated
pain-related stress did not produce significant alterations in physical
developmental milestones, including fur development, ear unfolding, eye opening
or eruption of incisors. A review of the literature indicates a lack of studies
systematically evaluating physical developmental parameters following repeated
invasive procedures in neonatal rat models. Therefore, the present findings
contribute additional information regarding the potential dissociation between
somatic developmental milestones and early-life pain exposure.
Behavioral
Responses and Vocalization in Preterm Neonatal Rats; Despite having unopened
eyes during the early postnatal period, rats exposed to repeated invasive
procedures appeared to recognize and respond to painful needle stimulation
beginning approximately on the second or third day of exposure. These animals
demonstrated escape-related behaviors during handling and produced pronounced
vocalizations when separated from the experimenter or subjected to procedures. The
observation that neonatal rats exhibited protective responses and increased
vocalization suggests that repeated painful experiences may be encoded even
during very early developmental stages. Such vocalizations may represent
instinctive defensive behaviors or communicative warning signals aimed at
increasing safety within the litter environment. To our knowledge, similar
behavioral observations related to early procedural pain exposure have not been
extensively reported in previous studies, highlighting a potentially novel
contribution of the present work.
Effects
of Repeated Invasive Procedures on In-Cage Social Behavior; Repeated invasive
procedures appeared to influence both dam–offspring interactions and sibling
relationships within the home cage environment. Intervention-exposed offspring
demonstrated increased aggressive and competitive behaviors compared with
non-exposed littermates. These animals were observed to disturb both their dams
and siblings more frequently. These findings may indicate that prolonged
exposure to pain and stress during the premature period contributes to
behavioral dysregulation later in development. Although extensive research has
examined neurodevelopmental outcomes following neonatal pain exposure, studies
specifically evaluating naturalistic social interactions within the home cage
remain limited. In this respect, the present study may provide a novel
behavioral perspective.
Effects
of Repeated Invasive Procedures on Motor Reflex Development; In the current
study, repeated invasive procedures administered during the first 10 postnatal
days did not significantly affect motor reflex development in neonatal rats.
Comprehensive assessment of multiple motor reflex parameters revealed
comparable developmental trajectories between experimental and control groups. A
review of the literature suggests that studies evaluating motor reflex
development following repeated neonatal invasive exposure in such a
comprehensive manner are limited. Therefore, our findings may help address an
important gap in the existing literature.
Effects
of Repeated Invasive Procedures on Behavior, Learning and Memory; The findings
of the present study demonstrate that pain and stress induced by repeated
invasive procedures during the premature period lead to increased fear- and
anxiety-like behaviors and negatively affect attention, learning, memory
performance and motor balance coordination in later life. These results support
the hypothesis that procedural pain and stress experienced by preterm infants
in neonatal intensive care units may contribute to neurodevelopmental
disturbances with long-lasting neurobehavioral consequences. Previous
experimental and clinical studies provide substantial evidence supporting these
findings. Vinall et al. reported that repeated or persistent pain exposure during
the neonatal period increases neuronal apoptosis and is associated with
anxiety-like behaviors in adulthood. Furthermore, pain-related stress
experienced in the NICU environment has been shown to alter spontaneous brain
activity at school age and negatively influence visual–perceptual development
in preterm children61. Similarly,
Ranger et al. demonstrated that the cerebellum of preterm infants is
particularly vulnerable to painful stimuli during early life and exposure to
neonatal procedural pain was associated with reduced cerebellar vermis volume
at seven years of age. Importantly, this structural alteration was linked to
poorer working memory performance62.
In another study, Cook et al. reported a negative association between increased
exposure to invasive procedures and later language performance in preterm
infants63. Large cohort studies
conducted by Selvanathan et al. further showed that greater exposure to
early-life pain adversely affects brain maturation and overall neurodevelopment
in very preterm infants64.
Consistent with these findings, neonatal invasive procedures have also been
associated with altered white matter microstructure, which in turn correlates
with poorer cognitive outcomes at school age among children born preterm65. Taken together, these findings support
the behavioral and cognitive alterations observed in the present study and
suggest that repeated painful stimulation during critical periods of brain
development may disrupt neurodevelopmental processes. Early-life exposure to repeated
nociceptive stress may therefore induce long-term alterations in cognitive,
emotional and motor functions, reinforcing evidence from both experimental
animal models and clinical human studies.
Effects
of Repeated Invasive Procedures on Responses to Painful Stimuli: In the
present study, preterm neonatal rats exposed to repeated invasive procedures
demonstrated reduced behavioral responses to painful stimuli in later life,
suggesting increased pain tolerance. This finding indicates that early repeated
painful experiences may modulate neurophysiological mechanisms involved in pain
perception and processing, potentially leading to an adaptive alteration in
nociceptive responsiveness. These results suggest that repeated exposure to
pain during the neonatal period may induce long-lasting changes in pain
perception. Such adaptations may manifest as increased pain tolerance or
hypo-responsiveness to noxious stimuli later in life, which may subsequently
influence neurobehavioral development. Previous clinical studies support this
interpretation. Grunau et al. reported that neonates exposed to greater numbers
of procedural painful events exhibited reduced cortisol responses to stress at
approximately 32 weeks of postmenstrual age. These long-term alterations have been
suggested to arise from the heightened vulnerability of brain regions rich in
glucocorticoid receptors, particularly the hippocampus and prefrontal cortex,
to early-life stress exposure66.
Effects
of Repeated Invasive Procedures on Brain Histopathology; In the present study,
repeated invasive procedures during the premature period resulted in increased
apoptotic cell counts in several brain regions of neonatal rats. These
histopathological alterations may contribute to persistent learning and memory
impairments as well as long-term behavioral abnormalities observed later in
life. Consistent with our findings, Anand et al. demonstrated in a neonatal rat
model that repeated pain exposure significantly increases neuronal apoptosis36. Similarly, Ranger et al. reported that
early exposure to repeated procedural pain has long-lasting effects on brain
development extending into school age, with greater exposure to painful
procedures in preterm infants being associated with reduced cortical thickness
in the frontal and parietal lobes at seven years of age63. Lammertink et al. further showed that
increased exposure to invasive procedures during the neonatal period delays
structural connectivity maturation within limbic networks, including the
hippocampus and amygdala, until term-equivalent age in preterm infants. Reduced
connectivity within these limbic structures has been associated with increased
behavioral problems during early childhood65.
Repeated procedural pain is known to trigger oxidative stress and inflammatory
responses, both of which may interfere with normal neurodevelopmental
processes. These mechanisms can impair the maturation of premyelinating cells
and disrupt myelination. Previous studies have indicated that pain-related
stress during the neonatal period affects pre-oligodendrocytes cells that
ensheath axons prior to differentiation into mature myelin-forming
oligodendrocytes thereby increasing vulnerability of the developing brain67. Taken together, the present findings are
consistent with experimental evidence demonstrating that both inflammatory pain
and repeated injections promote apoptosis in the neonatal rat brain, supporting
the hypothesis that early-life nociceptive stress may induce long-term
structural and functional alterations in the developing nervous system.
6. Conclusion
The present study demonstrates that pain and stress
induced by repeated invasive procedures during the premature period negatively
affect early-life body weight gain in neonatal rats and are associated with
increased anxiety-like, hyperactive, aggressive and competitive behaviors
within the home cage environment. Notably, despite having unopened eyes during
the early postnatal period, neonatal rats appeared capable of recognizing and
retaining painful stimuli, exhibiting behavioral responses suggestive of early
nociceptive memory formation. Exposure to repeated invasive procedures during
the premature period resulted in long-term neurobehavioral alterations,
including increased fear- and anxiety-related behaviors, impaired social
interaction and reduced learning and memory performance in later life. In
addition, decreased responsiveness to painful stimuli and impaired balance and
motor coordination were observed. Histopathological findings further revealed
increased apoptotic cell counts in the hippocampal CA1 region, dentate gyrus,
parietal cortex and prefrontal cortex, suggesting that early-life nociceptive
stress may contribute to structural alterations in brain regions critical for
cognitive and behavioral regulation.
Overall, these findings indicate that repeated
invasive procedures during critical stages of brain development may lead to
persistent behavioral and cognitive alterations extending into later life. From
a translational perspective, the results suggest that frequent invasive
procedures performed in neonatal intensive care units may have potential
long-term consequences for physical, behavioral and neurocognitive development
in preterm infants. Therefore, minimizing the number of invasive procedures
whenever possible, ensuring effective and safe pain management strategies and
increasing clinical awareness regarding both short- and long-term consequences
of neonatal pain exposure may be essential for improving neurodevelopmental
outcomes in this vulnerable population.
6.1.
Limitations of the experimental model
One limitation of the present study is that stress
hormone levels were not measured during the period of repeated invasive
procedures. Assessment of corticosterone levels through blood sampling during
the first 10 postnatal days could have provided additional insight into the
physiological stress response associated with repeated nociceptive exposure.
However, such measurements would have required the use of a larger number of
neonatal animals and therefore hormonal analyses were not performed in the
current study.
6.2. Conflicts of interest
The authors declare
no conflict of interest.
6.3. Funding
This study was not
funded by any organization or institution.
6.4. Acknowledgements
We would like to
express our deepest gratitude to the animal laboratory keepers and technicians
for their support of this project.
6.5. Ethics declarations
This study was
conducted after obtaining ethical committee approval from the Dokuz Eylül
University Local Ethics Committee for Animal Experiments, protocol number
09/2022.
7. References