Abstract
The role of mercury in the development of various neuropathologies is
well known. Biogeochemical cycles of mercury indicate the possibility of its
introduction into various organisms (including humans) through the
corresponding trophic chains. However, the literature analysis shows that until
recent years there have been almost no works on the dynamic microscopic study
(either in situ or in vivo) of the connectome involution in aquatic organisms
(including fishes, marine mammals, etc.) under the mercury exposure. In this
regard, we attempted to study the dynamics of morphogenesis and breakdown of
the emerging connectome upon the mercury exposure. Dynamics of the axonal
pathfinding / axonal guidance was carried out in a series of frames with an timecode
(address-time code), on which it is possible to track the motion estimation
vector fields of displacements and reaction-diffusion processes in the neural cell
culture immediately after the introduction of a drop of either mercury or a
mercury-containing liquid using capillary micropipettes. This paper describes
the effects observed and discusses the possible mechanisms underlying them.
Keywords: Mercury, Ecotoxicology, Axonal guidance,
Axonal pathfinding, Motion estimation, Vector fields
1.
Introduction
The role of
mercury in pathogenesis of various neuropathologies1,
including neurodegenerative diseases2, is well
known. In particular, it has been proven that mercury can cause the development
of Alzheimer's disease3-6. It can also lead to brain tumors7
and autism in children8,9, caused by the disrupted machinery of neuro(morpho)genesis
and disordered connectome development10. Such
effects may be due to the mercury exposure at the early stages of development11.
Similar effects are also observed in marine mammals12
- inevitably exposed to mercury due to its presence in seawater13-15.
Biogeochemical
cycles of mercury in oceans and near coasts, in littoral zones, etc.16-18
indicate the possibility of mercury incorporation into a wide variety of
organisms through the relevant food chains - up to seafood-eating humans19
and thus, actively (unlike most terrestrial organisms not engaged in the ocean “fishing”),
carrying out mercury into the cycles of terrestrial organisms. In freshwater
bodies (lakes20,21, rivers and their sediments22,23)
mercury can also exist and thus be distributed in freshwater and terrestrial
biogeochemical cycles. However, firstly, unlike the ocean, there is no a “single
pool” of mercury in freshwater bodies with its transfer by the global currents
or global migration of populations of individual species within the ocean; and secondly,
high mercury concentrations in freshwater bodies in many cases are a secondary
technogenic problem arising from the artificial mechanisms of the mercury extraction
and transfer in the biosphere / techno sphere. In other words, the effect of
mercury on neurogenesis of hydrobionts and, above all, oceanic fish and marine
mammals is the most representative example of this effect and hence, can be
used as a model.
However,
until recent years, there are very scarce works on the effects of mercury on
the development of the brain neural structure of marine mammals during natural
or model exposure to mercury and, moreover, there are almost no works on
dynamic observation of the development of their surviving brain slices upon
such exposure by time-lapse microscopy and multi-angle 3D imaging techniques
(confocal microscopy, SPIM, microtomography, holography and holographic
microscopy), which would answer the question of Hg-inhibitor diffusion in space
and time. How does axonal guiding / axonal pathfinding change with the
introduction of the amounts of mercury characteristic of natural exposure into
the nervous tissue? It is clear that in vivo exposure in marine mammals, most
likely, does not reach the extreme effects similar to those observed from the
long-term implanted amalgam carriers (such as the mercury-containing materials
widely used in dentistry in the 20th century24-29,
which is associated with an increase in the Alzheimer's disease statistics observed
by the end of the 20th century and beyond). However, at the level of single
neurons or single contacts and groups of contacts of connectomes even a
relatively low-intensity exposure should already have an effect but full-scale
studies of this on marine mammals have not been conducted.
An even less
explored issue is the reactivity of the fish nervous system to the introduction
of mercury into the environment. Analyzing the current literature in recent
years (since the author had not dealt with the fish nervous tissues since 201530,
due to the lack of equipment and facilities required for their maintenance), we
arrived to a paradoxical conclusion. Despite the increasing number of works
postulating the toxic effect of mercury on fish (up to its toxicokinetics and
biotransformation at various stages of this effect) and mercury contamination of
fish under various hydrochemical conditions19,31-40,
the number of works describing and interpreting this effect at the cellular
level, containing cytophysiological, immunohistochemical and morphometric data,
allowing to quantify the effect with the topographic reference, is extremely
small41. At the same time, it is obvious that direct
extrapolation based on single studies is impossible for all fish, at least due to;
the differences in neurogenesis and plasticity of the fish brain, depending on
environmental conditions, up to the dependence on the climatic conditions42,43;
the stress-dependence of morphogenesis and neuroanatomy of the fish brain up to
neuroendocrinological / sexual determination44-50; social plasticity at
different stages of development and under different living conditions51-53;
taxonomic and microevolutionary differences between different fish classes in
terms of neuronal organization and the prevalence of neurons of different
ergicity, moreover, with the reference to the specific areas of brain, more or
less reactive to mercury, depending on the morphophysiology or lifestyle of the
particular fish species, which makes it impossible to compare such effects even
in different fish taxa and not only to draw distant and unrepresentative
parallels between the effects of mercury in fish and in mammals54,55.
Moreover, due to topographic and anatomical reasons, differences in the effects
of mercury on fish and marine mammals should also be reflected in the brain
regeneration as well as in the effects of interhemispheric interaction and
behavioral asymmetry56,57.
Meanwhile,
within the framework of the “Cellular Basis of Behavior” paradigm by the Nobel laureate
E. Kandel, declared in his classic monograph of the same name58,
analysis of the hydrobiont behavior physiology should be based on
cytoelectrophysiological and morphological analysis of their neurons, as well
as the neural networks they form58. The study
was carried out in gastropod mollusks of bearded seals from the family Aplysiidae
(subclass Heterobranchia), as well as in the similar earlier works59.
That is, pathological changes in the behavior of aquatic organisms, as well as
in the behavior of the mammals eating them, caused by mercury, should affect
the axonal guidance during the connectome formation and, consequently, the
possibility of the signal propagation and transduction in the emerging neural
network. All of the above is based on the neuronal morphogenesis, which is
inhibited by mercury (which acts as an inhibitor of reaction-diffusion systems,
but, as a rule, not as a classical inhibitor (sensu stricto) in the Turing
model) and changes the directionality level / degree of the axonal pathfinding
/ axonal guidance, if such a heavy metal as mercury appears in the environment.
Considering the regeneration capabilities of the fish neurons60-62,
which are evolutionarily different from those in amphibians and mammals, but
still based on the same principles63, we can say
that not only the initial neurogenesis / neuromorphogenesis, but also
neuroregeneration in fish, which also requires the use of axonal guidance
mechanisms to restore the connectome, can be altered by the exposure to mercury
on the mature fish brain.
After all of
the above it seems that there should be a lot of works on the cultivation of
the cells or nervous tissues and surviving brain slices of fish in
mercury-enriched media, simulating the biological (marine) environment or biological
fluids of the fish body contaminated with mercury. But, in fact, this is not
true. A number of Eastern papers ask questions: what can we see in this kind of
study, except from the calculation of the mortality statistics for the
corresponding cells depending on the dose or exposure? Such a question formulation
is fundamentally wrong. We should talk about the basic mechanisms underlying
neuromorphogenesis and, in particular, axonal guidance and the mechanism should
be studied at the level of the single cell response58,
which should be registered not on the fixed sections post factum, but during
the cell development and regeneration (or degeneration of its processes /
axons, if the effect is irreversible). To date, there are specific fluorescent
probes for mercury ions64, which makes it possible to establish
colocalization between the content of mercury in a cell and biological
degeneration of its structure or activity, determined by the intensity of “luminance”
(fluorescence) of the other dyes (not interfering with the molecular probe for
mercury in the spectral range). There are also methods of scanning electron
microscopy in programmable atmospheres and in programmable liquid media with
controlled ion concentrations, which make it possible to trace local changes in
the mercury concentrations using low-vacuum X-ray spectroscopy (either wavelength-dispersion
or energy-dispersion detection) and map the sample composition by establishing
colocalization of the mercury content at diffusion interfaces and the state /
microstructure / ultrastructure of a biological sample in the given areas / ROI.
Unfortunately, we are unaware of similar studies carried out on the neurons of marine
mammals and even more on the fish neurons, although the experimental design
seems to be rather obvious. Therefore, our approach described in this work is
based on the simpler, but equally reliable methods providing dynamic study of
the frames with the axonal pathfinding dynamics in a series of registrograms
with a timecode, on which one can track the vector fields of movements and
reaction-diffusion processes in the neural cell culture immediately after the
introduction of a drop of mercury or a mercury-containing liquid using a
capillary or a patch clamp pipette. In this paper we describe this method for
the first time and test it on the data proving the effects of exposure to
mercury on neurogenesis. We have also initiated works on more complex neural
structures, but their results, due to the multiplicity of interacting elements
of the brain neural structure, are more difficult to describe and interpret and
require references to the unpublished data, that is why we decided to start
publication from a simpler version of the experiment known since the end of the
last century.
2. Materials and Methods
We used publicly available time-lapse footage of the axon growth and
axonal guidance of the mollusk neurons in the presence of mercury (posted on
the YouTube aggregator at:
https://youtu.be/XU8nSn5Ezd8;
https://youtu.be/FAWRYoYSAj4;
https://youtu.be/ewNvcFJEHbA;
https://youtu.be/Ipi3OneIw0A)
from the popular film "How Mercury Causes Brain Neuron Degeneration",
created by a team of authors from the University of Calgary (Faculty of
Medicine, Dept. of Physiology and Biophysics). Sequences of frames taken before
the introduction of mercury were taken as a control. To control the intrinsic
dynamics of disturbances in vector fields during the mercury diffusion (under the
conditions of advection and convection, which inevitably arise due to the
temperature difference between the introduced substance and the cultivation medium),
frames were taken for the first one and a half seconds after the toxicant introduction
into the medium, until the currents were established, which made it possible to
observe the dynamics and single neuron behavior without "convective
artifacts". As a control of the vector fields of the intrinsic neuron behavior,
we used the frames taken after the stationary state establishment in the medium
up to the final stage of involution (denudation) and destruction of trends in
the connectome formation.
To analyze
a series of film recordings / registrograms, we used the VirtualDub MSU Motion
Estimation Filter developed by the Computer Graphics Laboratory at the Moscow
State University (CS MSU Graphics & Media Lab; supervisor - Dmitry Vatolin;
the authors of the algorithm - K. Simonyan and S. Grishin). Vector field
visualization approach was used to analyze the object motions, which is also
used in aero/hydrodynamics in PIV (particle image velocimetry)65-68.
3. Results
and Discussion
The results obtained
and their description is shown in (Figures 1-5). Briefly, the experiment
demonstrates that:
For convenience of the readers, description of the processes observed in
the illustrations is given not in the text, but under the corresponding figures
allowing to compare the development stages of the processes observed in a
series of images. The author also tried not to overload this description with the
terms from the field of molecular neurobiology in order to ensure the
accessibility of the text and the method proposed for the readers working in chemical
ecology. Based on the material presented, it can be concluded that the vector
field method is effective in determining the axonal guidance dynamics in
environments contaminated with mercury or mercury-containing toxicants. In
addition, it is possible to speak about the specific cellular response
mechanisms and stages of the effect of mercury exposure in laboratory
conditions, using a staged interpretation of the flows visualized using vector
fields. It can be noted that the elements of dynamics completely invisible to
the human eye (fast-speed or too small-scale, as well as those carried out by the
structures with sizes of the order of several pixels, which are usually noted
as an obstacle to viewing the main picture) become visible in the vector field
algorithm and, in the case of detection of their regular nature and connection
with the object can generally be used to determine the intrinsic object's
properties. In this case all the questions about the cellular mechanisms of the
mercury effect on hydrobiont neurons in natural conditions become solvable,
since it is possible to reproduce almost any hydro chemical medium of the arbitrary
composition and to track even the most subtle cellular effects of axonal dynamics
restructuring of in it either in real time or in post-processing.
Figure 1:
Normal neurodynamics during axonal pathfinding. It can
be seen that both neurons generate directed impulses (co-directional
"vector packets") in the axon region, which should lead to the connection
formation. The branching neurofibers formed along these directions initially “probe”
a wide area in search of the other neurons to create a connectome and then,
having not received any response from the areas without neurons, focus their directions
on the area where the response is expected to be from the axons of the
neighboring neurons.
Figure 2: “High-speed” convective
and advective flows in the medium after the introduction of Hg into the cell-free
area using a capillary pipette or a patch clamp pipette.
Figure 3: Beginning
of denudation. One can observe the retrograde components of the fiber movements
shown by the arrow. At the same time, the second fiber (above the timecode)
inertially continues its axonal pathfinding until mercury diffusion reaches it.
The vector fields directed from it towards the fiber undergoing denudation in
order to establish connection with it are clearly observed (Figure 3e-3f).
However, compared to the control shown in (Figure 1), the intensity of
the axonal pathfinding from the second fiber is residual and the vector field propagation
in the area of mercury diffusion has almost terminated (the first descriptor of
neuro(morpho)genesis inhibition on the vector field maps is inhibition of the
neuronal “pathfinding activity”).
Figure 4:
Development of the denudation processes. Further structural involution is
detected by the intense retrograde paths visualized by the vortex phenomena on the
vector field maps and high-speed (visible by the long vectors) stochastic
retrograde motion (Figure 4a-4c), lasting up to the establishment of a
certain minimum stable somal form, which is further observed in the entire
series of images (Figure 4d-4f and Figure 5). Along with this, involution
of the upper axon (located above the timecode) is observed, in which not only
impulsive high-speed retrograde movements are fixed, synchronized with the similar
phenomena in another participant of the axonal guidance process (Figure 4c),
but shortening also begins, similar to that observed in the first neuron. At the
same time, as the retrograde movements progress and the branching fibers
shorten in both neurons, the “search field” (which in this sequence of frames
and, in general, in this experiment, is equivalent to the mercury diffusion
field) is cleared of the vector fields of mobility and axonal pathfinding.
Figure 5:
Terminal stage of the denudation process development (stationary state),
characterized by the absence of representative vector fields of motion
estimation (that is, from the point of view of mechanics, there is an almost
complete lack of mobility). If in the first images of this series (Figure 5a,5b)
one can still observe some movements in the medium within the area of the denuded
neurofibrils, then in the last images (Figure 5c,5d) almost the entire
field passes to a stationary state, excluding the terminal movement of the path
elements that have not yet formed (automatism at the level of cytoskeletal
elements, “supramolecular convulsions” in the jargon of colleagues from EMBL).
At the same time, the second participant in the process, which has reached an
almost stationary length, is still characterized (probably also due to the cytoskeleton
automatism) by the tight retrograde (and reversible) movements at a fairly high
speed, which can be registered by the "long" vector arrows in the
upper part of the image in (Figure 5c, 5d).
4. Conclusion
Production
of the aqueous media simulating freshwater, oceanic or marine environments with
an arbitrarily high complexity of the composition is not a significant
technical problem at the moment, up to the models that include microbiological
components, fluid models for specific geographical locations and specific light
exposure levels imitating photo- and hydrochemistry of mercury and the presence
of its specific dissolved or precipitated forms32,69-76. Moreover,
in the presence of modern trend reconstructing models (which is a consequence
of the “big data” analysis in natural ecosystems), adequate simulation is
available not only for the known environmental conditions, but also for the arbitrary
conditions for which a plausible calculation of the state in computational
models is possible. That is, in fact, there are no obstacles to modeling not only
statics and adaptation, but also the possible forms of the norm of reaction to
the mercury content in the evolutionary process or in bio(geo/hydro-) chemical
pathology.
Drawing
parallels between the mercury bioavailability for consumers of different
levels, including humans77-81, it is possible to implement multilevel schemes
of model systems, which will reproduce the conditions for mercury assimilation
in ecological chains as a whole and not just in individual organisms. As a
consequence, it is also possible to implement the schemes of installations with
a modified environment (analogues of stop flow or continuous flow techniques,
including their microfluidic implementations) to analyze the response of
different neurons and for preparations of different types of aquatic organisms
exposed to different hydrochemical conditions (in terms of Hg content). By
applying to such “microchemostatic” systems vector-field methods for analyzing
the results of microimaging obtained from inverted or lensless (which is
suitable only for very large neurons) microscopes, it is possible to study the neuron
pathfinding activity during axonal guidance depending on the environmental
conditions and the contamination dynamics. In our opinion, such prospects can
open a qualitatively new chapter in the history of mercury ecotoxicology,
especially in terms of its neurophysiological and neuroembryological effects.
5. Acknowledgments
The author
is grateful to M.A. Gradova for translation and proofreading of the text.
This paper
is an extended version of the MBEGA-2022 conference paper82,
so the author expresses gratitude to the conference organizers for the
opportunity to publish the primary material.
6. Conflict of interests
The author has no conflict of interest to declare.
7. References